Menu
The Goodman Institute Health Blog
  • Home
  • Authors
    • John C. Goodman
    • Devon Herrick, Ph.D.
    • Merrill Matthews
  • Popular Topics
    • Hits & Misses
    • Artificial Intelligence and Healthcare
    • Doctors & Hospitals
      • COVID-19 and Public Health
    • Policy & Legislation
      • Affordable Care Act
    • Health Economics & Costs
      • Cost of Healthcare
      • Drug Prices & Regulations
      • Health Reform
    • Health Insurance
      • Public Insurance
      • Medicare
    • Telemedicine
      • Medical Tourism
  • Goodman Institute
  • Contact
  • Search
The Goodman Institute Health Blog

Can I Get a Second Opinion? Yes, But It’s Sometimes Awkward

Posted on October 14, 2026 by Devon Herrick

The right to seek a second opinion is universally supported by doctors and patients alike, at least in theory. In practice it can be awkward. Many people turn to ChatGPT or another large language AI chatbots. But it is not as easy with human doctors. Do you quietly just try to see another doctor? Or do you tell your doctor, “I want a second opinion because I think you’re wrong.” Some specialists will not see you without a referral. The following is from Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF) Health News:

When Carol Daniel, a veteran broadcast journalist who lives near St. Louis, was diagnosed with thyroid cancer in 2022, her husband encouraged her to seek a second opinion. She was worried that consulting another doctor might seem like a betrayal.

Daniel said she wondered: “Am I cheating on him? Am I going behind his back? Am I acting like I don’t trust him by seeking a second opinion?”

Many patients find themselves in this position, but family medicine physician Jen Caudle said patients shouldn’t feel awkward about asking for a second opinion. In fact, in her practice in New Jersey, she encourages people to have open conversations with their care team.

“We shouldn’t be offended,” Caudle said. “We should support you.”

Patients can also think of their primary care provider as the quarterback of their care team, Caudle said, and ask that doctor for help navigating opinions or diagnoses from specialists.

I recently had a health complaint and went to see my doctor. She didn’t really know what was causing my condition and ordered a test, which was inconclusive. I asked another doctor and he wasn’t sure either and suggested I see another specialist. Contrast this scenario to one where your doctor suggests a medical intervention and you wonder if he or she is wrong. Or if a recommended course of action is the only one. 

This time last year we took our dog, Clementine, to her regular vet for a recurring bladder infection. Surgery for bladder stones had failed to solve her problem and the veterinarian suggested another surgery of dubious merit. We had to insist he refer Clementine to a veterinary internist for a second opinion. He agreed and Clementine was later diagnosed with bladder cancer. As sad as that was, at least Clementine didn’t have to endure needless surgery. 

There are times when a second opinion is for questions like, “Do I need back surgery or would physical therapy help. Ask an orthopedic surgeon and you will likely get a different answer than if you ask a Doctor of Physical Therapy. Especially for cancer, you may want to seek numerous opinions about the best course of action. Cancer is too complex to rely on just one oncologist. 

Sometimes a second opinion is to avoid spending on unnecessary care. One suggestion that I always tell people is to let your doctor know you are price sensitive. Ask if you really need that MRI, or can you wait and see. Or ask if you can shop around for prices rather than getting care from a hospital setting. My doctors have all been good about helping me.

KFF Health News: The Sometimes-Awkward Art of Asking for a Second Opinion

1 thought on “Can I Get a Second Opinion? Yes, But It’s Sometimes Awkward”

  1. Pingback: The Economist: Many Surgeries Little Better than a Placebo – The Goodman Institute Health Blog

Join the conversation. Cancel reply

For many years, our health care blog was the only free enterprise health policy blog on the internet. Then, when the NCPA closed its doors, the health blog stopped as well.

During this five-year hiatus no one else has come forward to claim the space. So, my colleagues and I have decided to restart the blog in connection with the Goodman Institute. We invite you and others to use this forum to share your views.

John C. Goodman,

Visit www.goodmaninstitute.org

Subscribe via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 46 other subscribers

Popular Topics

©2026 The Goodman Institute Health Blog | Website by Lexicom